Should Everton bring back Jack Rodwell?

Over the last couple of days there have been growing rumours of a potential return to Goodison Park for academy graduate Jack Rodwell. The Birkdale born youngster is still only 22 years old, but has already packed a lot into a fractured career that, despite been regularly disrupted by injury, has always been one of promise and potential.


Ninety-seven Premier League appearances, three caps for England and a big money move to the then champions of England, Rodwell has achieved a great deal in his fledgling football career, but it is perhaps his unfulfilled potential that Jack Rodwell is best known for. After bursting onto the scene as a huge talent at just 16 year of age, Jack Rodwell appeared to have all the attributes to become a huge Premier League star. A strong physical presence, was perfectly complemented by his ability on the ball. It is very rare to find a player so at ease with the ball at his feet, but Rodwell is assured and appears to have unlimited time when in possession. Unfortunately and probably most telling in his career to date, has been a lack of belief to become the world-class player that his undoubted talent deserves.

Throughout his time at Everton he struggled to establish himself as a first team regular and he was always the first to make way with Moyes preferring the security of experience, rather than placing his full trust in youth. It would be fair to say that Rodwell’s approach didn’t fit well with the tactics of David Moyes, but the transition made at Everton during the opening few months of the Roberto Martinez reign, would make him a perfect fit alongside McCarthy as the long-term successor to the brilliant Gareth Barry.

It is rather sad that 15 months into a 5 year contract, the talk is of Jack returning to his boyhood club, with his move to Manchester City turning sour. The first year of that deal was constantly interrupted by persistent trouble with his hamstring, the same injury which curtailed his involvement during his final 18 months at Everton. But even if Rodwell was to manage a prolonged injury free run, it is hard to see him figuring for Pellegrini’s Manchester City. The Chilean manager has made Fernandino and Yaya Toure his preferred two in midfield and his baffling persistence with the awful Garcia, means that in all likelihood, Rodwell is at very best, fourth choice for a midfield berth.

A number of Evertonians weren’t too disappointed when Rodwell was sold on, especially considering the fee the club received from Sheikh Mansour’s Manchester City. £12 million represented excellent business for Everton and that fee may yet rise to £15 million over the next three years. But there is always a feeling of disappointment and regret when one of the clubs bright Academy prospects is sold on without fulfilling his potential and it would be wonderful to see an Everton midfield featuring the exciting talents of Ross Barkley and Jack Rodwell.

What are your thoughts on the potential return of Jack Rodwell? Would he fit seamlessly into the plans of Roberto Martinez?


12 thoughts on “Should Everton bring back Jack Rodwell?

  1. I would bring him back. But only as a centre half, that is his real natural position. Great in the air and has great timing in the tackle and uses the ball coming out of defence.

  2. I’d have him back in a heartbeat. Cover in Midfield and potentially a successor to Distin. But then, I’d have Joleon back too and offer to take Micah as well.

  3. If Rodwell is fit then he will play against Newcastle tomorrow night and so will get a chance to stake his claim to be in the 1st XI. If he is not playing that basically means he is still injured.

  4. I think we should stay far away from Rodwell, he is even worse then Gibson with all his injuries, we do not need more injury prone players.

  5. I agree with Jimmy, Rodwell career has flat-lined since his Goodison departure. He offers nothing more than what Everton already have in the middle, so no thanks.

  6. He seems unable to string a number of games consecutively to prove he is not injury prone. Therefore the fee would have to depend on appearances. I wonder if he has the passion to win his place in our ever improving team. It would be a gamble!

  7. @StDomingos1878 I always thought Jack was slow to impose his influence on games. I’d have him back, hoping Martinez can help him improve.

  8. @StDomingos1878 I would have him back think he can still be a good player but would it be worth spending the ££ necessary to bring him back

  9. @StDomingos1878 ah, Sideways Jack. Good player, comfortable on the ball, can tackle, more of a fetcher and carrier than defence splitter.

    Would have to be certain his injuries are sorted. A possibility but can we afford his now ludicrous wages c£90k p/w

What do you think? Why not post a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s